Lorem Ipsum Dolor Sit Amet Consectetur Adipiscing! Get Started

The Rearview #7: Who Now?

I wrote that money does not fall from the sky, about the spectacular climb and even more spectacular drop of Mega Fortris, GIIB and Ni Hsin. I asked questions and made no accusations. I still make none. But the story has a new chapter.

On 10 November, Bursa Malaysia issued trading reminders on GIIB and Ni Hsin; Mega Fortris had received its own on 6 November. In each case, the message was that unusual trading had persisted despite the companies’ replies to Bursa’s unusual market activity (UMA) queries, and investors should be careful (New Straits Times; BusinessToday).

The three counters at a glance

Mega Fortris GIIB Ni Hsin
Business Security seals Rubber compounds Cookware; EV venture
Datuk Ng’s stake about 67% about 15.8% 2.22%
The rise 87.5 sen (Jan) to RM3.45 11 sen (Apr) to 74 sen 7 sen (Aug) to 50 sen
Peak 27–28 Oct 26 Oct 28 Oct
Trading reminder 6 Nov 10 Nov 10 Nov
Price at reminder RM1.34 12 sen 9.5 sen
Fall from peak about 61% about 84% about 81%
Gain needed to recover peak about 157% about 517% about 426%

Prices from The Edge, New Straits Times and BusinessToday. Mega Fortris price is at midday on 6 Nov; GIIB and Ni Hsin are closing prices on 10 Nov. Percentages are my own rounded calculations.

A reason on the way up, none on the way down

To be fair, Bursa did not sit idle during the climb. GIIB received two UMA queries after its April surge and pointed to a planned move into healthcare. Ni Hsin was queried in September, having announced a diversification into electric vehicles (The Edge; New Straits Times). The queries were answered with a story, the story was accepted, and the rallies carried on.

The way down was a cliff. In two days at the end of October, Mega Fortris fell from RM3.45 to RM2.22, and GIIB and Ni Hsin each lost about half (The Edge). This time the replies said almost nothing: a court order over share trades from March, a resale of treasury shares that may or may not have mattered, and from GIIB, no reason at all.

A rise came with a reason. A fall came with none. “We don’t know” should have been the louder alarm.

A reminder at the bottom

Yet the public heard nothing more for a week. In that silence, all three bounced on 2 November, drew buyers back in, then collapsed again. When the reminders finally came, the shares were at their lowest since the rise began, as the table shows.

Whom does a reminder at the bottom serve? Perhaps the bargain hunters; more than 86 million Ni Hsin shares changed hands on 10 November alone. But think of those who bought near the top and are still holding on, licking the wounds of a paper loss. To break even, they now need gains of 157% on Mega Fortris, more than 400% on Ni Hsin and more than 500% on GIIB. Some may never recover.

The reminder tells them nothing their statements had not, except that the exchange is now uneasy too. For some, that may be the final push to sell at the worst price and turn a paper loss into a real one.

A reminder at the top protects buyers. A reminder at the bottom mostly frightens holders.

And the brokers?

Bursa is not the only gatekeeper. Stockbroking houses have their own discretion. They can require cash upfront from clients, or withhold contra and margin facilities, on any counter they judge too risky, without waiting for the exchange. Did any of them do so while these shares were climbing sixfold and sevenfold? I have seen no sign of it. Rising prices meant heavy volume, and heavy volume meant brokerage fees. Profit, it seems, is a powerful sedative for risk.

Yet when brokers do reach for such curbs, it tends to be after a counter has been beaten down to its core. By then, the curb protects the broker’s own book from clients who cannot pay, more than it protects the clients. It also makes it harder for those still holding to average down at the bottom. Cash upfront at the top saves investors. Cash upfront at the bottom mostly saves the broker.

In fairness to Bursa

A trading reminder lags by design; it needs days of persistence to observe. The rebound may have looked like stabilisation, and warnings fired too fast can cause the panic they aim to prevent. Bursa did suspend intraday short selling in Mega Fortris (The Edge), and much surveillance happens out of public view. But rules that serve the market should be judged from the cheap seats.

So, who now?

The companies say they do not know. Bursa has reminded us to be careful. Who will tell us what actually happened? Who sold at the end of October? Were shares pledged and force-sold? Is there a link to the March trades in the court order? These are not accusations, and only Bursa’s surveillance, the Securities Commission and the court can answer them.

There is another way to read “who now?”: who is left holding these shares? The major shareholders will survive this, whatever their paper losses. The people who may not are the retail investors who chased the rise on a story, or bought the bounce on hope. For many of them, this was not spare speculation money but hard-earned savings. Every share sold in this collapse was bought by someone, and it is that someone who now waits, perhaps for years, for a recovery that may never come. When we ask who should answer, we should also remember who is still waiting for the answer.

What the regulator could do

It is easy to criticise from the rearview mirror, so here are a daydreamer’s suggestions.

Ask harder questions on the way up. A reply that says “we plan to diversify into healthcare” should be followed by: what timeline, how much money, what revenue? A story that cannot survive those questions should not carry a share price.

Treat “we don’t know” as a trigger. A public reminder could follow within a day or two, not a week.

Use the speed bump Bursa already has. It can declare a counter a designated security, requiring cash upfront from buyers. It did so with Iris Corp in 2006 after a more than tenfold rise in eight months, Harvest Court in 2011 and Icon Offshore in 2020, citing excessive speculation (The Star; The Edge). Why not earlier, and more often, on counters that rise multifold on a story?

Tell us who is trading: when a few accounts dominate volume, or major shareholders have pledged their shares.

Flag it where investors look. A warning label on the trading screen reaches them before they press “buy”.

Close the loop. Say when a matter goes to the Securities Commission, and publish the outcome.

Back to the sky

Money does not fall from the sky, and neither do warnings arrive on time. If new facts emerge, my opinion may change. As I said in #0, I carve my ethics in stone and write my opinions in sand.

References:

  • The Edge Malaysia, “Two companies linked to businessman Ng Meng Kee see sharp dive in share price, Bursa queries one of them”, 29 October 2026.
  • New Straits Times, “Ni Hsin plunges 20pct in early session after Bursa query”, 30 October 2026.
  • The Edge Malaysia, Ni Hsin UMA reply coverage, 30 October 2026.
  • The Edge Malaysia, “Mega Fortris, GIIB and Ni Hsin rebound after last week’s sell-off”, 2 November 2026.
  • The Edge Malaysia, “Mega Fortris continues slide after two-day rebound, GIIB and Ni Hsin extend losses”, 4 November 2026.
  • The Edge Malaysia, “Mega Fortris, GIIB, Ni Hsin recoveries wiped out as shares sink even lower than last week’s rout”, November 2026.
  • New Straits Times, “Bursa urges caution as Mega Fortris rout deepens”, 6 November 2026.
  • BusinessToday, “Bursa Issues Notice After Mega Fortris Share Price Plunge 51%”, 6 November 2026.
  • New Straits Times, “Ni Hsin, GIIB continue sliding as Bursa flags trading”, 10 November 2026.
  • BusinessToday, “Bursa Issues Trading Reminder On Ni Hsin After Sharp Price Plunge 41% Today”, 10 November 2026.
  • BusinessToday, “Bursa Closes Lower As Heavyweight Selling Knocks 12.51 Points Off FBM KLCI”, 10 November 2026.
  • The Star, “Bursa’s move likely to cool down exuberant rise of penny stocks”, 16 November 2011.
  • The Edge, “Icon Offshore declared a designated stock due to excessive speculation”, 24 January 2020.

This column reflects the author’s personal views and does not constitute investment advice.

Dr Paul PK Lim is the de facto towkay of Accoris Management Sdn Bhd, and he loves to daydream.

Share

Categories

We are a team of qualified and highly competent professionals who are here to unlock the value and potential of your business. We believe in creating value for your business by embracing the latest technology and up to date information to make the difference. We simplify complexity in your day-to-day operations to save time and cost with the depth and breadth of our expertise.
Contact Us

Accoris Advisory Sdn Bhd

2011010143852 (971972-T)

cosec@accoris.my (603) 7727 0033 / 8033

Accoris Consulting Sdn Bhd

202001041863 (1398184-V)

consult@accoris.my (603) 7732 2955

Accoris Management Sdn Bhd

202501056855 (1658261-V)

consult@accoris.my (603) 7732 2955

Accoris Tax Services Sdn Bhd

202601012559 (1674657-P)

tax@accoris.my (603) 7732 2955